Energy earth’s bankruptcy



Introduction

In 2017, there was unbelievable news among Thai investors. The well-known company in Thailand named “Energy Earth Public Company Limited" was bankrupted by the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC).

The Company imported Bituminous Coal from Indonesia to domestic and international customers by sourcing through coal mines of Company Group in Indonesia through TTP (Tri Tunggal Pitriat), whose 99.99% of shares were held by the Company and through trading with other mine owners in Indonesia through EPCL (Energy Earth Public Company Limited), whose 99.99% of total shares were also held by the Company.

Presently, the stocks had been prohibited to trade. In this blog, we will try to explore what happens to the company.
Causes of the bankruptcy


Which banks are involved in Energy Earth's bankruptcy?

End of a quarter 1, 2017, there was large liabilities; 23,000 million Baht of Energy Earth Public Company Limited.

Liabilities:
Bill of exchange 2,382 million Baht
Trust receipt 5,308 million Baht
Packing Credit 4,791 million Baht
Bank loans 4,213 million Baht
Bonds 5,475 million Baht


Thanachart Bank (TBANK)

➣ Parties and loans payable
➣ EARTH accused Thanachart Bank disclosing their confidential information to Krung Thai Bank. And then, EARTH sued Thanachart Bank in order to recover damages.

➣ However, after the bad news of Thanachart Bank was published, the stock price of them (TCAP) decreased 2% within a day.
➣ Thanachart Bank informed The Stock Exchange of Thailand (SET) that they had not received a summons from the court. In addition, they recriminated back to EARTH.

Krung Thai Bank (KTB)

➣ Loans Payable
➣ KTB loaned 10.2 billion Baht without collateral. Basically, loaning the large credits must be permitted by the senior executive managing director, but it was permitted by the middle managers.

➣ KTB suspended EARTH’s credits because EARTH did not allow to check the coal sales agreement from KTB. There might be the corrupted officers of KTB.
➣ KTB accused EARTH making an illegal copy; B/L (Bill of lading) in order to be loaned evidence.  

Kasikorn Bank (KBANK)

➣ Parties and loans payable
➣ KBANK opposed the proposal for making a group of creditors.




Bank of Ayudhya (Krungsri/BAY)

➣ Loans payable
➣ BAY suspended EARTH’s credits.



Export-Import Bank of Thailand (EXIM Bank)

➣ Loans Payable
➣ There was a contract which EARTH was able to lend 10 million US dollars (around 350 million Baht).


Bank of Thailand (BOT)

➣ BOT followed the impact of EARTH’s default closely.
➣ BOT urged Thanachart Bank to clarify the information after EARTH sued for damages. Pointing out that financial institutions were prohibited from disclosing information. There was a condemnation of the information leaders to publicize.


What happens after the bankruptcy? and
what are the creditors' actions?

On 2 August 2018, the creditors agreed to accept the rehabilitation plan and gave EY Corporate Advisory Services as the rehabilitation planner. However, Central Bankruptcy Court considered and disapproved EARTH's rehabilitation plan on 15 November 2018, causing all administrative and management powers to be transferred from EY Corporate Advisory Services to the directors of EARTH from now on.

After the Central Bankruptcy Court disagreed with the rehabilitation plan of Earth, the creditors have to resume operations themselves.

"Solving the debt problem from EARTH is not easy. Because there are many creditors. The debt is quite large, and in the past, each bank creditor had to negotiate with EARTH because it was considered that different people were lending in the same project, but they did not share the loan. Kasikorn Bank has fully reserved such bad debts because it became non-performing loans (NPL) more than 1 year." said Pridi Daochai, Managing Director of KBANK.

For EARTH creditors, which are financial institutions, consisting of
➣ Krung Thai Bank (KTB), payable of 12,000 million Baht
➣ Kasikorn Bank (KBANK), payable of 3,800 million Baht
➣ Bank of Ayudhya (BAY), payable of 1,200 million Baht
➣ The Export-Import Bank of Thailand (EXIM Bank), payable of 300 million Baht, including a loan of nearly 20,000 million Baht, which Exim Bank is considering according to the major creditors how to proceed. In addition, Krung Thai Bank is now proceeding to prosecute the executives and officers who were involved in lending to EARTH.

More information

References
➣ Retrieved from http://longtunman.com
➣ Retrieved from https://www.prachachat.net/finance/news
➣ Retrieved from http://www.thansettakij.com
➣ Retrieved from https://www.ryt9.com
➣ Retrieved from https://www.efinancethai.com
➣ Retrieved from https://thaipublica.org  
➣ Retrieved from https://mgronline.com

Comments